I enjoy American Idol, but it also annoys me.
First off, they must lose those cheesy Ford commercials. Aside from giving absolutely zero useful information to a prospective car buyer, the stupid campy themes and the silly costumes and even sillier plastered on smiles just really grate on me. If one of the purposes of commercials is to create in your mind an image, then I must say that those commercials have convinced me that Ford is something like a circus, without the acrobatics and juggling. Ford Motor Company, if you’re listening, please know that I’m not particularly interested in Ford automobiles at the moment, but if I were, those commercials surely would’ve changed my mind, as I don’t think I could sleep at night knowing that I subsidized such silliness.
Second, their voting system seems whacked. There is just something wrong with having people vote for their favorite and then kicking off the person with the lowest number of votes. It seems like a logical system, what’s wrong with it? Well, let’s see, the 5 or 6 times that somebody was kicked off which was such an obvious shock that they had to just about apologize and warn us that we must never assume our favorites are safe and we must continue to vote for them. The American public remembers these warnings for probably 1 week and then we revert to taking it for granted that everyone realizes that our favorite is the best. The problem is that with the current system, people tend to choose between two strategies: voting for their favorite or voting to save the person who is not the best but appears to be in danger of leaving the show. The latter could be called “the sympathy vote” and it leads to people neglecting the obvious favorites out of the false assumption that everyone else will vote for them. It seems to me to be not unlike UI design: if users continually don’t grasp the system, then you should fix the system rather than trying to fix the users. Consider the classic UI design Principle of Least Astonishment — the assertion that the most usable system is the one that least often leaves users astonished. American Idol astonishes the American public all too often, and not in good ways. E.g.: the untimely departure of Chris Daughtry (my one consolation is that Chris no longer has to appear on those inane aforementioned Ford commercials). My idea is to have us vote for the person that should be kicked off – more straightforward, no surprises. I know you’re probably thinking that this is just too sadistic and that soccer moms and teenagers (particularly renowned for their emotional sensitvity and aversion to any form of cruelty) won’t take to it. I think it will work. Look up schadenfreude. The word is imported from Germany, but unlike wienerschnitzel, I think we can really master this one.
Third, after singing covers for a season, at the end of the show the final two sing “their first singles”. These songs inevitably sound like they were dispensed from some kind of pop single vending machine. The algorithm for creating such songs seems to boil down to something like this:
- Choose theme and lyrics that epitomize achieving one’s greatest dreams. Good words to use here: dreams, passion, faith, high, soaring, eagles, and clouds. Words to avoid: failure, disappointment, death, politics, and taxes.
- Choose a random Celine Dion song, take the chords and apply them to step 1. Michael Bolton also would work quite well here. The singer, not the character from the movie Office Space.
- Make sure that song begins soft and slow and builds to a magnificient crescendo.
- When song has reached the absolute peak of above-mentioned crescendo, now it’s time to append a key change.
- Now that the key change has kicked in and the answer to the question “how much higher could this song go?” is “none more higher”, it’s time to bring out the choir of gospel singers. If anyone in the audience is still left standing, then those ladies in long blue gowns will finish the job. Blue is critically important for the color of the gowns as it is the wavelength of light that induces awe.
- Note that pyrotechnics and confetti are great, but should only be used once the winner of the show has been proclaimed. Visual effects are great, but should be saved for the finale. Personally, I think a dancing gorilla could really put things over the top here, but no one has been brave enough to try this yet.